To set the scene, this house is a 4 year old new build with new build carpets (in case you haven't ever experienced this delight.....it is cheap carpet thrown on top of whatever surface was left - in this case, it was cracked, plaster splashed dusty and dirty concrete). 4 years of prams, dogs, visitors and the joys of dirt from the building site outside on poor quality carpet wasn't great.
It's a shame I can't show how it started out, even if I had a photo, it would never be a fair side by side comparison so just imagine showhouse cream carpet - after 4 years and countless attempts at cleaning, this was the very sad result.
Stained, bubbled, awful. It had to go, it was unsafe and unhygienic.
The final decision after months of samples and discussion was vinyl tiles.
I know the price is high, and ridiculously high depending where you go (but more of that later) but it also comes with a 15 year guarantee for commercial use and I believe a lifetime guarantee for domestic use so it's clearly robust. I know from experience that any freak damage can be rectified by removing and replacing tiles - not easy, but possible. When you compare the initial cost with the cost of probably replacing the other types of flooring over 15 or more years, the figures are easier to handle.
In the end, the decision between Amtico and Karndean came down to colour, I wanted something a bit darker in a wood effect and the one that suited the best was Karndean Rubra (WP316 if you are interested).
The cost....this was an adventure! I went to several suppliers and the costs varied by £2000. In the end, I was lucky enough to have worked with a flooring contractor in the past who was able to do it for a sensible price. Although I had a previous connection, this wasn't 'mates rates', it just wasn't the ridiculous mark up that the shops added.
The result - It's a bit controversial in that the direction is technically wrong, the main living room should run away from the door and not across it and unlike most vinyl tile floors it doesn't have a border. This is purely because I wanted the flooring to flow through the whole ground floor, which it does. Plus, with such wide planks (36"x6") the border would either have to be cut down (extra labour costs) or make the hall really narrow.
Some more photos to show the flow between rooms and the detail. It's been down for a few weeks now and so far so good. I'll come back with an update if I fall anymore in love or if any problems crop up.